PS5’s controller vs. the Xbox Collection X controller: Head-to-head

A brand new technology approach a brand new wave of controllers, and this time, the diversities between the PS5 and Xbox Collection X’s controllers are moderately dramatic. Selecting the controller that’s proper for you’ll be the verdict that tilts you in opposition to one console over the opposite. To assist you make a decision, we’re breaking down the DualSense and the brand new Xbox controller to peer which has the threshold.

PS5 or Xbox: Which controller is inexpensive?

We’ll get started with a very simple one. Whilst each the PS5 and Xbox Collection X consoles include a controller, purchasing further controllers will price you. A brand new PS5 Dualsense controller will run you $69.99, while the brand new Xbox controller prices $59.99. This worth distinction will turn into transparent as we dive into the options of the brand new controllers.

Xbox Series X video game console photographed on a dark gray background

Picture: Henry Hargreaves for Polygon

PS5 or Xbox: Which controller is extra comfy?

This will likely actually come down to private choice. At this time, the one particular person at Polygon who has used either one of the brand new controllers is, uh, me. In my view, I to find the PS5’s DualSense extra comfy to carry for lengthy sessions of time, because of its longer handles and triggers that have compatibility extra naturally into my resting index palms. The brand new Xbox controller’s smaller handles are an growth at the previous design, however I’m no longer certain in regards to the new, stiffer triggers, which appear to require a lot more power than the previous Xbox One triggers did.

That stated, different contributors of the Polygon crew have reported some hand cramping with the PS5 DualSense, so it’s closely dependent readily available measurement and luxury personal tastes. Onerous to mention, however for those who pressured me to select, I’d move with the PS5 DualSense.

PS5 or Xbox: Which controller seems higher?

Every other subjective one, however whats up, you’ve come to me. I’ve brazenly stated I despise the PS5’s large white and black tower of a console. And but, the design of the DualSense controller works for me. The white and black, combined with the delicate glow from the touchpad, seems fairly furitistic with out being overwhelmingly so. It’s additionally were given some nifty main points, like a teeny tiny development of the acquainted “form” buttons performing because the grip at the handles.

Picture: Henry Hargreaves for Polygon

The brand new Xbox controller’s aesthetics aren’t unhealthy in anyway. Just like the black dice of a console, the brand new Xbox controller does a greater process of disappearing into the background of your residing area than the DualSense does

However in contrast to most of the different knowledge issues right here, you’ll be able to simply make a decision this one for your self, because of our beautiful pictures.

PS5 or Xbox: Which controller has extra options?

This isn’t even a competition. The PS5’s DualSense provides a number of main options that its predecessor didn’t have. The adaptive triggers, which modify the strain of the triggers in keeping with what’s taking place on display screen, are unbelievable. As are the brand new haptics, which make the controller’s vibrations way more correct and sundry. The DualSense additionally has a returning touchpad, a gyroscope for movement controls, and a integrated speaker.

The brand new Xbox controller brings with it all the options that the Xbox One controller had and provides a Percentage button and an progressed D-pad. However lots of the internals are just about the similar as what used to be within the Xbox One controller.

Close-up of the analog sticks on a PS5 controller

Picture: Henry Hargreaves for Polygon

PS5 or Xbox: Which controller has higher battery lifestyles?

But any other no-contest class, however this time it’s the brand new Xbox controller that takes it (with some caveats). Losing two AA batteries into it will have to grant you between 30 to 40 hours of gameplay time. This will likely range moderately, however general it’s lovely excellent bang on your dollar. In case you’d quite no longer blow thru disposable batteries, Microsoft does make a Play and Rate Package for the brand new controller. We haven’t used it, but when it’s anything else just like the remaining one, it will have to provide you with 20-30 hours in keeping with fee (with diminishing fees over the process a number of years).

The PS5’s DualSense comes with a battery pack in-built (one more reason for the upper worth). We haven’t completed in depth battery trying out, however early teardowns have proven that the battery pack has about 50% extra capability than the DualShock 4’s battery pack. The DualShock Four used to be rated for round six hours in keeping with fee, which might put the DualSense within the nine-hour vary. However, as a result of all the new bells and whistles within the controller, this battery lifestyles may well be a lot much less, relying on how a lot is getting used. A recreation like Astro’s Playroom, which continuously makes use of the fanciest DualSense options, is prone to drain your battery a lot sooner, as an example.

an overhead shot of the Xbox Series S controller sitting on beige carpet next to a pair of AA batteries, with a Nintendo-branded USB-C cable plugged into it

Picture: Maddy Myers/Polygon

It’s additionally price remembering that DualShock Four controller batteries tend to peter out after a number of years of use, providing dramatically much less time in keeping with fee. And, just like the DualShock 4, the brand new DualSense’s rechargeable battery isn’t detachable, so you could have to plunk down any other $69.99 if yours dies an early dying. That may no longer be splendid.

PS5 or Xbox: Which controller is extra flexible?

Again within the Xbox 360/PlayStation three days, having a Microsoft controller round used to be a boon because it supposed you must use the Xbox controller on each your PC and your console. Sony’s controller, in the meantime, used to be a lot much less pleasant to different gadgets.

Occasions have modified since then, with the Xbox and PlayStation controllers enjoying great with all varieties of gadgets, from PCs to pills to telephones.

Xbox Series X video game console photographed on a dark grey background

Picture: Henry Hargreaves for Polygon

However, in relation to rapid ease of use, the brand new Xbox controller is move on PC, simply as a result of its ubiquitous fortify there. You gained’t have to fret about messing with drivers or different settings with an Xbox controller on PC. It will have to simply paintings. Sony’s DualSense, in the meantime, will most probably want distinctive drivers to paintings correctly. Video games that labored advantageous with a DualShock Four don’t appear to serve as in any respect with the DualSense, and might want to be patched (an issue for older video games that can by no means see patches). Those problems might easy out through the years, but it surely’s laborious to mention when or if the DualSense will simply “paintings” on PC and different platforms.

PS5 or Xbox: Which is the simpler controller?

Oof, guy, actually hanging me at the spot, huh? As you’ll be able to see from the above, there are advantages to each controllers. For versatility and battery lifestyles, you actually can’t beat the Xbox controller. In the meantime, the PS5 controller packs in fashionable options that can make enjoying sure video games much more attractive (as long as such things as haptics and adaptive triggers are supported by way of the sport). For sheer audacity and ambition, it feels just like the PS5’s DualSense has the threshold right here, however for those who’re in search of a multi-platform workhorse, move with the Xbox controller.

The Xbox Collection X can be launched international on Nov. 10, adopted by way of the PlayStation Five on Nov. 12. For this overview, Polygon examined an Xbox Collection X (and the brand new controller) equipped by way of Microsoft, and a PlayStation 5 (and DualSense controller) equipped by way of Sony. Vox Media has associate partnerships. Those don’t affect editorial content material, despite the fact that Vox Media might earn commissions for merchandise bought by means of associate hyperlinks. You’ll be able to to find further details about Polygon’s ethics coverage right here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *