Replace: Ema – who labored on a fork of the CSE2 model of Cave Tale – has gotten in contact to elucidate some issues:
1. This DMCA is precisely for CSE2, the fanmade decompilation of the unique freeware model of Cave Tale. Mentioned freeware model is unaffected via the takedown, and can also be downloaded at cavestory.org as at all times.
2. To the most efficient of our wisdom, Nicalis in reality owns the Cave Tale IP. We haven’t any reason why to consider that this DMCA takedown is unlawful in anyway. Whilst there can also be truthful use exceptions for decompilations like CSE2, the weight of evidence rests at the venture, no longer at the copyright holder.
3. Nicalis has a historical past of being very supportive to the modding neighborhood. At this level, we do not suspect any sick will. We’re coming near Nicalis in an try to transparent up this false impression.
4. The maintainers of CSE2 haven’t any goal of disparaging Nicalis. It is via their just right will that the modding neighborhood continues to thrive above flooring. We unilaterally endorse the legit industrial variations of Cave Tale.
Authentic Tale [Thu 26th Nov, 2020 09:30 GMT]: Writer Nicalis is issuing DMCA takedown requests towards websites which give the freeware model of the enduring indie Metroidvania Cave Tale, it’s been claimed.
Created via Eastern developer Daisuke “Pixel” Amaya over a length of 5 years, Cave Tale was once launched on PC in 2004 and briefly was well-known with enthusiasts of indie titles. Nicalis got here on board in 2010 to port the sport to WiiWare and DSiWare, and in addition produced the improved Cave Tale 3-D on 3DS in 2011. Cave Tale+ – according to an up to date model launched on Steam – was once transformed to the Transfer in 2017.
In spite of all the more than a few retail variations to be had, the unique laptop model of Cave Tale has remained a freeware product and can also be freely disbursed on-line, and a mod neighborhood has grown up across the sport.
Twitter person Buttons Sir Bernard Law posted the next message (caution: unhealthy language) on November 24th, together with a screenshot appearing proof of a DMCA takedown understand:
So @nicalis has made up our minds to begin DMCA’ing the freeware variations of Cave Tale and fan made rebuilds of the freeware model that supported mods whilst additionally in large part no longer even the usage of the unique supply code.
Have in mind: F**okay Nicalis. Don’t toughen Nicalis. Don’t purchase Nicalis video games.
The tweet was once noticed and reshared via famed indie developer Rami Ismail (he of Vlambeer status, the studio in the back of Ridiculous Fishing, Luftrausers, and Nuclear Throne), who then posted the following message:
Cave Tale is among the maximum essential video games each made and I will be able to 100% suggest you don’t purchase it. Obtain the freeware unique, then purchase Kero Blaster to toughen the real developer of the sport, as a substitute of those unpleasant shenanigans.
Probably the most builders in the back of a CSE2 fork – which is a “decompilation” of Cave Tale which has “an emphasis on accuracy to the unique code” – has additionally replied to the unique tweet, losing just a little extra gentle on why the takedown request was once filed:
I am the principle dev in the back of a big CSE2 fork, so I would love to transparent some stuff right here!
Successfully, CSE2 was once a decompilation venture of the unique Freeware unlock of CS. Apparently Nicalis bought the code of it once they were given the IP. The DMCA was once stuffed as a result of that.
The DMCA claims Nicalis owns the code to CS+ and believes stated code exists within the repos, however that isn’t the case to our wisdom.
A number of primary members within the CSE2 venture (myself incorporated) are lately making plans to manner nicalis to settle at the subject.
It is value noting that Cave Tale stays to be had for obtain on websites equivalent to cavestory.org, even though, on November 24th, that individual website online was once up to date with the next message:
Got rid of hyperlinks to the CSE2 repo because of the DMCA takedown. A observe in regards to the CSE2 DMCA takedown was once added on each the “obtain” and “customized engine” pages.
Consistent with the Cave Tale Group Encyclopedia, Cave Tale is approved to Nicalis however is owned via Amaya; subsequently, it might seem that Nicalis is overstepping the phrases of its licensing settlement via looking to snub out freeware variations of the sport – even though there are were rumours that Nicalis has “duped” Amaya out of the rights to the sport (this video does a just right task of overlaying or even disproving those stories). No matter settlement Nicalis has with Amaya, it has allowed the corporate to place characters from Cave Tale into different video games its has revealed or advanced, together with the puzzle name Crystal Disaster and the preventing sport Blade Strangers.
This is not the primary time that Nicalis has been accused of questionable behaviour. Final yr, a record via Kotaku alleged that the corporate was once ghosting possible industry companions and Nicalis boss Tyrone Rodriguez was once stated to have used slurs and mistreated his group of workers.
We have now approached Nicalis for remark and can replace this tale if and once we listen again.